Owner’s Draw vs. Salary: Your Pay Decisions

Key Takeaways

• The salary method involves paying yourself a regular wage, while the draw method involves taking money out of the business as needed.
• Your business structure is important in determining how you should pay yourself.
• Both salary and draw methods have pros and cons and tax implications.
• Accurate record-keeping is crucial, regardless of the way you choose.
• The concept of reasonable compensation lacks standardized criteria, leading to subjectivity and potential disputes.
• Professional accounting services can provide essential guidance on compensation decisions.

Owner’s Draw vs. Salary: The Difference

Before comparing the salary method to the draw method, it’s essential to understand the basics of each. Both methods are common ways small business owners pay themselves, but they function differently and have unique tax implications.

Understanding Owner’s Draw

An owner’s draw is a method by which business owners withdraw funds from their business for personal use. This can be done at any time and in varying amounts, depending on the business’s profitability. Draws are not subject to payroll taxes at the time of withdrawal but are considered personal income and taxed accordingly when filing taxes.

Tax Implications

• Draws are not subject to payroll taxes at the time of withdrawal.
• They are considered personal income and taxed when filing taxes.
• Owners must set aside funds to cover their tax liabilities since taxes are not withheld at the time of the draw.

Flexibility

Owners have the flexibility to adjust the amount and frequency of draws based on business performance. This means they can take larger draws during profitable periods and smaller ones when cash flow is tight.

Impact on Business Equity

Taking an owner’s draw reduces the equity of the business, as it directly withdraws funds that could otherwise be reinvested.

Understanding Salary Method

The salary method involves paying yourself a set amount of money on a regular pay period, similar to any other employee. Salaries are subject to payroll taxes, including Social Security and Medicare, which are deducted automatically from each paycheck. This provides a more straightforward tax process for the owner.

Tax Implications

• Salaries are subject to payroll taxes, including Social Security and Medicare.
• Taxes are deducted automatically from each paycheck.
• Provides a more predictable tax process for the owner.

Predictability

A salary offers predictable income, which can aid in personal budgeting and cash flow management for both the owner and the business.

Regulatory Compliance

For certain business structures like S Corporations, paying a reasonable salary is required by the IRS to ensure compliance with tax regulations regarding reasonable compensation.

Pros and Cons

Owner’s Draw

Pros

• High flexibility; can be adjusted as needed.
• Can take larger draws during profitable periods.
• Taxes are not deducted at the time of withdrawal.

Cons

• Draws can create income instability.
• Each draw reduces business equity.
• Taxes must be managed separately, which can complicate tax planning.

Salary

Pros

• Predictable income aids in personal budgeting.
• Taxes are automatically withheld, simplifying tax processes.
• Can make qualifying for personal loans and mortgages easier.

Cons

• Less flexibility in adjusting payments based on business performance.
• Salaries are subject to payroll taxes, which can increase overall tax liability.
• Requires compliance with employment laws and regulations.

Which Payment Method is Right for Your Business?

The profit distribution method you use to pay yourself largely depends on your business entity’s legal and tax classifications. Below is a comparison table outlining which payment method is recommended for different business structures.

How to Pay Yourself from Your Business Account

1. Determine Your Payment Method: Decide whether you’ll use the salary or draw method based on your business structure and financial needs.
2. Set a Reasonable Compensation: If you choose the salary method, ensure your salary reflects the value of your work and meets minimum wage laws.
3. Schedule Your Payments: Set up a regular pay period for a salary. For draws, decide how frequently you’ll withdraw money.
4. Record the Transaction: Make sure to record each payment in your accounting system correctly.
5. Handle Tax Implications: Ensure you’re withholding enough for taxes if you’re on a salary. Remember to set aside money for income and self-employment taxes if you’re drawing.

Tax and Compliance Considerations

If You Are a Sole Proprietor

Your business profits are considered income in your personal account. Therefore, you’ll need to pay personal taxes on your business profits, regardless of how much you draw. This means you’re responsible for paying self-employment taxes, covering Social Security and Medicare. These taxes are usually higher than employees’ payroll taxes, so planning for this additional tax liability is essential.

You can deduct legitimate company expenses to reduce your taxable income. However, the owner’s draws are not deductible as company expenses.

If You Are in a Partnership

Your share of the business profits is reported on your tax return, and you pay income tax. Like sole proprietorships, partnerships are not separate tax entities, so the partners pay taxes on their share of the business profits, not on their draws. However, a partnership agreement can specify how profits (and losses) are split among partners. This agreement can also dictate how often and how much each partner can draw from the business.

One important point is that partners are not considered employees for tax purposes. This means you can’t receive a salary or wages from the business. Instead, you may receive what’s known as a “guaranteed payment,” which is essentially a predetermined amount that’s independent of the partnership’s profits or losses.

If You Are in an LLC

How you’re taxed depends on how the LLC is structured for tax purposes. An LLC can be a disregarded entity (like a sole proprietorship) or a partnership, or it can be taxed as a corporation (S Corp or C Corp).

The tax treatment is similar to a sole proprietorship for single-member LLCs treated as disregarded entities. You pay taxes on the business profits, not on your draws. For LLCs treated as partnerships, the tax treatment is similar to a partnership. The profits are distributed according to the LLC agreement, and each member pays taxes on their share.

If the LLC is treated as a corporation for tax purposes, then you, as a member, can be an employee and receive a salary. In this case, the tax treatment is similar to that of a corporation.

Reasonable Compensation and IRS Guidelines

Determining a reasonable salary is crucial if you pay yourself through the salary method, especially for S Corp owners. The IRS requires you to pay yourself a “reasonable compensation” for your work. This salary is comparable to those of other business owners in similar roles and industries. You can research comparable salaries using industry surveys, professional associations, or job posting sites.

Why Reasonable Compensation Matters

These guidelines are crucial because they prevent business owners from deliberately paying themselves below market value to misrepresent their company’s finances. This is particularly relevant for C-Corps and S-Corps, as partnerships and sole proprietorships are not typically subject to these rules. If your salary is too low, the IRS may reclassify some of your business profits as wages, which could increase your tax bill.

Challenges in Determining Reasonable Compensation

Despite their importance, the guidelines for reasonable compensation can be somewhat subjective and lack straightforward calculation methods. Tax and legal professionals have noted this challenge, emphasizing the importance of considering all relevant facts and circumstances when setting your salary. This makes thorough research and documentation essential for compliance.

Conclusion

Choosing between a salary or taking an owner’s draw depends on many factors, including your business structure, profitability, cash flow, and personal financial needs. While the salary method provides more stability, the draw method offers more flexibility. However, both methods have tax implications that need to be carefully considered.

Remember, keeping accurate records of your payments, whether a salary or a draw, is essential. This will help ensure that your business finances stay organized and that you’re prepared for tax time.

For personalized advice tailored to your specific situation, consider consulting with a professional accounting service.

People Also Read

• Form 3800 Instructions: A Comprehensive Look for Beginners
• Schedule SE: Your Guide to Self-Employment Taxes
• Form 8858 U.S Foreign Disregarded Entities for U.S Taxpayers
• Unemployment Overpayment Wage Garnishment: All Your Questions Answered